Faithful voters

By Tom Quiner

Catholics are funny voters.

They historically vote Democrat. The Democratic Party was once the party of the little guy. Catholics were not warmly welcomed into this country, and politics helped them overcome the pitfalls faced by the “little guy.” Democrats embraced and assimilated Catholics.

Now that the Democratic Party, or as I characterize them, the “Take Away Party,” no longer looks out for the little guy, Catholics are not the reliable Democratic voters they once were.

George W. Bush won the Catholic vote twice.

Barack Obama won them back to the Take Away fold twice again.

Yesterday, Catholics voted Republican 53 to 45% according to exit polling conducted by Edison Research. Protestants were even more supportive of Republican candidates, 60 to 38%.

Probing the data more deeply, white Catholics voted Republican 59 to 39%. And weekly church goers of all faiths voted 58% for the GOP. To turn that around, the less religious a voter is, the more likely he/she will vote Democrat.

The data also reveals that 65% of the Hispanic vote (which is also heavily Catholic) voted for the Take Away Party. This number reveals the tremendous opportunity Republicans have in the years to come. Right now, this growing constituency views the Democrats as the Give Away Party. They want to be the recipient of their bounty.

Republicans need to craft a positive message presenting themselves as the Opportunity Party to win over more of these voters.

American Catholics could dominate American politics if they voted in alignment with Church teachings. But there’s the rub. Conservative Catholics like myself view the Republican Party as the most reliable protector and implementer of Catholic social justice teachings. Liberal Catholics, inexplicably, see it just the opposite.

That is what makes politics so interesting.

Congratulations to Republicans on their sweeping victories yesterday.



  1. Shawn Pavlik on November 5, 2014 at 11:45 am

    How does the left’s pro-choice stand square with Catholic teachings?

    • quinersdiner on November 5, 2014 at 1:54 pm

      It totally flies in the face of Catholic teaching, which states that human dignity is conferred at conception and retained until natural death. Even more, Catholic theology is animated by scripture that states that God knew us before we born. Even more, Catholic teaching believes that creation is the fruit of marriage, and that marriage is based on the union of one man and one woman. These have been our teachings for 2000 years. They will never change. Many Catholics disagree with Church teachings on these subjects, or believe that they are offset by other equally pressing issues, such as immigration reform or poverty concerns. I don’t see how anything could be more pressing than life and death issues like human abortion. Now you know why I blog.

  2. oarubio on November 5, 2014 at 1:43 pm

    An investigation of “liberal” Catholics will likely show that they are really pseudo-Catholics (a la Biden, Pelosi, Sebelius and the rest of that gang)!

    • quinersdiner on November 5, 2014 at 2:00 pm

      I think is too broad a statement, Tony, even though my gut instinct is to agree with you. Pelosi and Biden are jokes, so I don’t feel a need to deal with them. I do know sincere Catholics who put more weight on certain issues than others, such as immigration reform and the war on poverty than abortion and gay marriage, for example. They embrace Church teachings, but are more passionate about these “liberal issues” than abortion/marriage concerns. But you are correct that some are dubious Catholics since they so resoundingly reject critical Church teachings.

  3. […] Quiner’s Diner, “Will the ‘Take-Away Party’ lose their power today?”, “The Republicans’ triumph is even more amazing when you look at this map” and “Faithful voters” […]